An honest look at family finances
2 Mar
I’ve come to the realization that the value of my house will most likely drop below what I paid. Which is depressing. Luckily, we shouldn’t ever be upside down since we put down a decent sized down payment and have paid extra along the way. But still, it sucks. We paid $184,000 and it’s currently worth $189,000 on Zillow. This is down from $350,000 at the high.
This knowledge sure makes me think differently about buying a home. Don’t get me wrong. I’m glad we own, I’m fine with what we paid, and we don’t plan to sell for a very long time. But even though we bought our house, not as an investment, but as a place to live, I still had the mind set that we would make money on the deal. It wasn’t a conscious thought. I didn’t buy the house thinking that we would get out every penny we put in. But somehow the whole “get rich off real estate” thing sunk in. I see now that I was fully expecting to always have more equity than I had paid in payments.
For example, we have paid about $83,000 towards the house including our down payment and interest. Right now, according to Zillow, we have about $45,000 in equity. Which under my old thinking, that means we’ve lost $38,000. Which in a way, I guess we have. If we hadn’t bought this house and saved all our money we would have $83,000 instead of $45,000.
But let’s think about it a little more. We have also lived in this house for 4 1/2 years. How much would we have paid in rent over the course of 4 1/2 years? According to Rentometer our house rents for about $1,300 a month. So over the past 4 1/2 years we would have paid $70,200 in rent and we would have no equity at all.
So what does that mean? Well, we’ve paid about $13,000 more to buy our house than to rent it. And in return we have $45,000 in equity. We are still ahead. So far. But how much more will it drop? Who knows? But no matter what we will continue to stick it out. I truly believe that in the end we will come out ahead. I guess the hard part is letting go of the guarantee that the market would pay us to live here.
pic by: asianjournalusa
Thanks for reading. If you enjoyed this post consider subscribing!
Post Footer automatically generated by Add Post Footer Plugin for wordpress.
Related posts:
7 Responses for "Our house is worth what we paid… over 4 years ago."
We figured our “break even” point on our home. If we can sell it in three years for a little more than we paid, we will have broken even over paying rent. Which means that we lived here for $0 — which is nicer than paying tens of thousands in rent. Plus, we should have a nice chunk of money that we can use as a down payment on our next home. It is depressing, but I do feel a little better, since the mortgage interest deduction we got this year meant that — for the first time in years — we actually got a tax refund.
Very interesting post Ashley! Thanks.
Oh yeah of course houses have been massively overpriced. The British market was even more overheated than the American. I say this because right during the most soaring times I heard of homes going (OK probably quite scummy tiny falling apart houses, but homes nonetheless) on the shores of choppy northern lakes for UNDER $100,000 which is amazing! That was £50,000 at the time. The average starter home in London was $250,000 and that’s for a TINY pokey not even 1-bed but studio flat…
Having seen values leap I can tell you that in London they are approximately THREE TIMES what the property’s actually worth.
OK I’m not an economist, it’s just having watched over the years… the situation is utterly ridiculous…
Awesome post! What I loved is that you took into account how much rent you would have paid. You are so smart!!
Interesting post. I should calculate that as well.
That’s some pretty good calculations ya got going on there! i love it
We were underwater 6 months after buying - but whatcha gonna do ya know? Maybe i’ll see how much we saved in rent + the tax stuff and see what happens….although our house lost $60k so far.. interesting either way!
[...] Wide Open Wallet: Our House Is Worth What We Paid… Over 4 Years Ago [...]
Leave a reply